| Platinum | Napoli's Café |
| Gold | Vittoria Trattoria |
| Silver | Di Rienzo Deli |
| Bronze | Cabotto's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Babbos Cucina Italiana |
| Top Pick | Bella's Boys |
| Top Pick | Cucina da Vito |
| Top Pick | Giovanni's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Poco Pazzo |
| Top Pick | Roger's Italian Bistro |