| Platinum | Meatings Barbecue |
| Platinum | Moe's BBQ |
| Gold | Fatboys Southern Smokehouse |
| Silver | Junior and The Kid |
| Bronze | Fatboy Burgers (Sheffield Rd.) |
| Top Pick | All Seasons Indian Catering |
| Top Pick | Bâton Rouge |
| Top Pick | Big Bone BBQ & Wicked Wings |
| Top Pick | Riggins Family BBQ |
| Top Pick | The Smoque Shack |