| Platinum | Louis' Pizza |
| Gold | Colonnade Pizza & Restaurant |
| Silver | River Pizza |
| Bronze | Vittoria Trattoria |
| Top Pick | Boston Pizza St-Laurent |
| Top Pick | Fiazza Fresh Fired |
| Top Pick | Gabriel Pizza (Hunt Club @Bank) |
| Top Pick | Heartbreakers |
| Top Pick | Jojo's Pizza & Subs |
| Top Pick | La Dolce Vita |
