| Platinum | Country Perks Cafe |
| Gold | SuzyQ |
| Silver | Oh So Good Cafe |
| Bronze | Franks Baked Goods |
| Top Pick | Holey Confections |
| Top Pick | La Catrina Churros + Dessert Bar |
| Top Pick | Simply Biscotti |
| Top Pick | The Cupcake Lounge |
| Top Pick | The Hintonburg Public House |
| Top Pick | Three Tarts |
